The Agricultural Imperative: How Western Protectionism Threatens Global Food Security While the Global South Forges Ahead
Published
- 3 min read
The Americas’ Crucial Role in Feeding the World
The Western Hemisphere stands as the undeniable cornerstone of global food security, with Brazil, the United States, Argentina, Mexico, and Canada comprising the world’s top five agricultural producers by volume. This region not only produces staple crops like soybeans, corn, wheat, and rice but also diverse specialty crops including coffee, avocados, citrus fruits, and quinoa. Agriculture contributes significantly to national economies across the Americas, often representing over 5% of GDP and exceeding 10% in several cases.
Between 1990 and 2015, Latin America and the Caribbean achieved what no other region could—halving hunger rates—demonstrating the remarkable progress possible when nations prioritize food security. However, this progress faces severe threats from interconnected factors including ecological degradation, geopolitical instability, inflationary pressures, and slowing productivity growth. The very systems that enabled this agricultural success now face unprecedented challenges that demand urgent, transformative responses.
The Gathering Storm: Ecological and Geopolitical Threats
Ecological risks represent perhaps the most immediate threat to food security across the Americas. Climate change, deforestation, biodiversity loss, and soil degradation threaten to undermine agricultural productivity precisely when global demand increases. The combination of drought and heat—so-called “hot and dry” conditions—poses particular concern for crop yields, with the terrifying possibility of simultaneous failures across multiple breadbasket regions.
Simultaneously, geopolitical turbulence erodes the multilateral trading systems that have facilitated global food distribution. The article reveals how China’s shifting agricultural import patterns—now favoring Brazil over the United States—demonstrate the realignment of global food trade along South-South axes. This reorientation challenges Western dominance in agricultural markets and represents a significant step toward food sovereignty for Global South nations.
Western Protectionism: The Neo-Colonial Threat to Food Justice
The rising tide of protectionism in Western nations represents nothing less than a neo-colonial assault on global food security. While the article discusses how current protectionism affects more crops and involves more countries than the targeted tariffs of the 1990s, it fails to adequately contextualize this within centuries of Western agricultural imperialism. The United States’ imposition of tariffs on Brazilian agricultural products in August 2025 exemplifies how Western nations weaponize trade policy to maintain dominance over Global South food systems.
This protectionism isn’t merely economic policy—it’s a deliberate strategy to undermine the agricultural advancement of developing nations. When Western powers disrupt South-South agricultural trade through tariffs and sanctions, they perpetuate a colonial dynamic where Global South nations remain suppliers of raw materials rather than architects of their own food futures. The decay of multilateral institutions that once provided some protection against such predatory practices leaves developing nations increasingly vulnerable to Western economic coercion.
Brazil’s Agricultural Leadership: A Beacon of South-South Solidarity
Brazil’s emergence as the world’s largest soybean exporter, particularly through its strengthened trade relationship with China, represents a powerful counter-narrative to Western agricultural dominance. This shift demonstrates how Global South nations can forge mutually beneficial partnerships that bypass Western-controlled systems. Brazil’s agricultural success story—achieved despite Western economic pressure—offers a blueprint for how developing nations can achieve food sovereignty through South-South cooperation.
The potential for regenerative agriculture practices in Brazil, particularly the revitalization of degraded pastures, represents not merely an environmental opportunity but a civilizational choice. By choosing sustainable methods that work with rather than against ecological systems, Brazil and other Global South nations reject the extractive agricultural model imposed during colonial eras. This approach honors indigenous knowledge systems and traditional farming practices that Western agricultural corporations have long dismissed as primitive.
The Demographic Challenge: Western Failure Versus Global South Innovation
The aging farmer demographic crisis particularly affects wealthier regions like the United States and European Union, revealing the failure of Western agricultural models to create sustainable livelihoods. Meanwhile, the article suggests innovative approaches emerging across the Americas to make agriculture financially, socially, and culturally attractive to new generations. These solutions—including reduced barriers to entry, training programs, and highlighting agriculture’s technological aspects—demonstrate how Global South nations are leading the way in addressing systemic challenges that Western models have exacerbated.
The contrast between Western agricultural decline and Global South innovation couldn’t be starker. While Western nations cling to outdated protectionist policies and ecologically destructive farming methods, developing nations are pioneering regenerative approaches, technological integration, and South-South trade partnerships that offer hope for a more equitable food future.
Toward Food Sovereignty: Rejecting Western Dominance
The path forward requires fundamentally rejecting Western-dominated food systems and embracing approaches centered on food sovereignty, ecological sustainability, and South-South cooperation. The proposed “A5” group comprising the United States, Brazil, Mexico, Canada, and Argentina must not become another vehicle for Western agenda-setting. Instead, Global South nations within this group must assert leadership and ensure that any hemispheric food security council prioritizes the needs of developing nations over Western corporate interests.
Investment in agricultural innovation must focus on appropriate technology—solutions that empower smallholder farmers, respect ecological limits, and remain accessible to communities rather than corporations. The Western model of patent-protected, corporate-controlled agricultural technology has failed to address hunger while enriching multinational corporations. The Global South must develop and share technologies through open-source platforms that prioritize human need over profit motive.
Conclusion: The Agricultural Future Belongs to the Global South
The food security challenges facing the Americas reveal deeper truths about global power dynamics. Western nations, having exploited agricultural systems worldwide during colonial eras, now seek to maintain control through protectionist policies and corporate domination. Meanwhile, Global South nations like Brazil demonstrate that alternative models centered on sustainability, sovereignty, and South-South cooperation offer more promising paths forward.
The ecological crisis, demographic shifts, and geopolitical realignments demand nothing less than a revolutionary approach to food systems—one that centers traditional knowledge, rejects extractive economics, and builds resilient networks outside Western control. The future of food security depends on our ability to dismantle neo-colonial structures and build systems that honor the dignity, sovereignty, and wisdom of Global South nations.
As civilizational states with ancient agricultural traditions, India, China, and other Global South nations possess the historical depth and cultural wisdom to lead this transformation. The time has come to reject Western agricultural imperialism and embrace food systems that nourish both people and planet while honoring the sovereignty of all nations to determine their agricultural futures.