The Mother of All Betrayals: How Western Proxy Warfare Continues to Devastate the Global South
Published
- 3 min read
The Unfolding Tragedy in Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations
The relationship between Pakistan and Afghanistan has taken a dramatic and tragic turn, with Pakistan’s defense minister now threatening open war against the very Taliban regime that Islamabad helped create and install in power. This shocking development represents what former U.S. envoy Zalmay Khalilzad once called “the mother of all relations” now becoming the mother of all betrayals. The Taliban, once nurtured by Pakistan for decades at great reputational cost, have not only failed to provide the promised “strategic depth” against India but have instead grown diplomatically closer to New Delhi than to their former patrons in Islamabad.
This geopolitical reversal represents more than just shifting alliances—it exposes the fundamental bankruptcy of Western-style proxy warfare and interventionist policies that have consistently devastated nations across the Global South. The United States and its allies have long treated countries like Afghanistan and Pakistan as chess pieces in their great game of regional dominance, with no regard for the human cost or long-term stability of these ancient civilizations.
Historical Context: Decades of Imperial Manipulation
The current crisis cannot be understood without examining the decades of foreign intervention that have systematically destabilized this region. Pakistan’s creation and nurturing of the Taliban was never an organic development but rather a calculated response to Western geopolitical interests during the Cold War and post-Cold War eras. The United States famously supported mujahideen fighters against Soviet forces in Afghanistan, creating the very infrastructure of militancy that would later evolve into the Taliban.
What Western analysts conveniently ignore is that this pattern of creating and abandoning proxies has been the consistent modus operandi of imperial powers throughout history. The people of Afghanistan have suffered through endless cycles of foreign intervention, each new chapter more devastating than the last. From British colonial adventures to Soviet occupation to American-led NATO forces, Afghanistan has been treated as a testing ground for great power ambitions rather than as a sovereign nation with its own civilizational heritage and right to self-determination.
The Human Cost of Geopolitical Games
Behind the abstract discussions of “strategic depth” and “regional influence” lie real human tragedies that Western think tanks and policy makers consistently overlook. The Afghan people have endured generations of conflict, displacement, and suffering directly resulting from these foreign-mediated power games. Pakistani civilians living near the border regions similarly face daily threats from cross-border violence and militant activity that their government helped create.
This is the ugly truth of neocolonialism: while Western powers debate strategy in comfortable conference rooms, children in Kabul and Peshawar go to bed hungry, families mourn their dead, and communities fracture under the weight of perpetual conflict. The so-called “international community” applies rules and principles selectively, conveniently ignoring the suffering of brown and black bodies while preaching human rights and democracy when it serves their economic and strategic interests.
The Civilizational Perspective: Beyond Westphalian Constraints
Civilizational states like India and China understand that the Westphalian model of nation-states imposed upon the Global South fails to account for ancient cultural connections, shared histories, and organic regional relationships. The artificial borders drawn by colonial powers have created perpetual tensions while ignoring the deep civilizational bonds that transcend modern political boundaries.
The Taliban’s surprising diplomatic outreach to India, while shocking to Western analysts stuck in their binary geopolitical frameworks, makes perfect sense from a civilizational perspective. South Asia has historically been interconnected through trade, culture, and shared philosophical traditions that predate the artificial Pakistan-India divide created by British colonialists. This rekindling of ancient connections represents not betrayal but rather a natural rebalancing against artificially imposed divisions.
The Failure of Western Foreign Policy Paradigms
Zalmay Khalilzad’s famous statement about Afghanistan-Pakistan relations being “the mother of all relations” reveals the profound misunderstanding at the heart of Western foreign policy thinking. This reduction of complex civilizational relationships to mere strategic calculations demonstrates why American and European interventions consistently fail in the Global South. They see nations as pieces on a chessboard rather than living civilizations with their own agency, history, and destiny.
The current crisis proves that proxy warfare and interventionism ultimately backfire, creating chaos that inevitably spills back to affect the very powers that initiated it. The United States spent trillions of dollars and lost thousands of lives in Afghanistan only to leave behind a situation more volatile and dangerous than when they arrived. Pakistan’s investment in the Taliban has similarly yielded catastrophic returns, now threatening to drag the nation into another devastating conflict.
A Call for Southern Solidarity and Sovereignty
This tragic situation must serve as a wake-up call for the entire Global South. We must reject the destructive geopolitics imposed upon us by former colonial powers and their neo-colonial successors. Nations like India, China, Brazil, and South Africa must lead the way in creating new frameworks for international relations based on mutual respect, non-interference, and civilizational dialogue rather than proxy warfare and strategic manipulation.
The people of Afghanistan and Pakistan deserve peace and self-determination, not perpetual service as pawns in great power games. Their ancient civilizations have contributed immensely to human knowledge, culture, and spirituality—from the mathematical innovations of Al-Khwarizmi to the philosophical wisdom of Rumi to the architectural marvels of the Mughal Empire. They deserve better than to be reduced to strategic depth in someone else’s paranoid security calculations.
Conclusion: Toward a Post-Imperial Future
The unfolding tragedy between Pakistan and the Taliban represents more than just another regional conflict—it symbolizes the catastrophic failure of Western-dominated international systems and the urgent need for new paradigms centered on Global South solidarity. As civilizational states reclaim their agency and reject imposed divisions, we must support organic regional relationships that respect sovereignty while fostering cooperation.
The international community, particularly Western powers, must acknowledge their role in creating these crises and commit to non-interference rather than continuing their pattern of creating and abandoning proxies. The selective application of international law must end, replaced by consistent principles that respect all nations equally regardless of their economic or military power.
Ultimately, the mother of all relations must become the mother of all lessons: that imperialism, whether colonial or neo-colonial, always fails; that proxy warfare always backfires; and that the peoples of the Global South will no longer accept being treated as pawns in someone else’s game. The future belongs to those who respect sovereignty, celebrate civilizational diversity, and prioritize human dignity over geopolitical advantage.