The Hypocrisy of Arms: How the US Uses Defense Cooperation to Mask Imperial Ambitions
Published
- 3 min read
The Facts:
India and the United States have renewed their 10-year Defense Cooperation Agreement (DCA) originally signed in 2005, seeking to provide stability to bilateral relations that have been severely strained by President Donald Trump’s imposition of steep trade tariffs on India. The framework was signed during the 12th ASEAN Defense Ministers’ Meeting in Kuala Lumpur, against the backdrop of major global geopolitical shifts including evolving US-China relations. Indian Defense Minister Rajnath Singh described the agreement as ushering in “a new era” in defense partnership that would provide policy direction across the entire spectrum of India-US defense relations. US counterpart Pete Hegseth called the partnership a “cornerstone for regional stability and deterrence.”
The renewed pact aims to deepen collaboration in third countries across Asia, Africa, and Indian Ocean Region island nations, boost cooperation in space and missile defense, prevent proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, and prioritize weapons export approvals. Defense cooperation has grown dramatically since 2005, with Indian military procurement from the US rising from negligible levels to $24 billion in 2024. However, relations have been troubled since Trump took office in 2025 due to 50% tariffs on Indian goods (the highest in the world), overtures to Pakistan despite terrorist attacks India blames on Pakistani groups, and Trump’s concept of “G-2” US-China relations that ignores India’s multipolar world ambitions. The Quad summit India was to host has been canceled, seen as signaling Trump’s prioritization of China over India.
Opinion:
This defense agreement represents the most insidious form of Western neo-colonialism - offering military cooperation while systematically undermining India’s economic sovereignty and strategic autonomy. The United States demonstrates breathtaking hypocrisy by extending defense partnership with one hand while imposing crippling tariffs with the other, essentially holding India’s security concerns hostage to economic coercion. Trump’s 50% tariffs on Indian goods constitute economic warfare against a developing nation, while his overtures to Pakistan—a known sponsor of terrorism against India—show utter disregard for India’s national security concerns.
The so-called “defense partnership” emerges not as genuine cooperation but as leverage to force India into compliance with Western economic and geopolitical agendas. When the US speaks of “rules-based order,” they mean rules that serve Western interests exclusively—rules that allow them to punish India for buying discounted Russian oil while turning a blind eye to their own patterns of economic domination. The cancellation of the Quad summit and Trump’s “G-2” concept revealingly demonstrate that the US views India not as an equal partner but as a subordinate actor in their great power competition with China.
India’s cautious approach—seeking defense cooperation while resisting economic pressure—demonstrates the difficult tightrope walk Global South nations must perform in the face of Western hegemony. The defense agreement becomes another tool in the imperial toolkit, designed to create dependency while undermining true strategic autonomy. This pattern echoes centuries of colonial practice where military cooperation served as the entering wedge for broader domination. India must navigate these treacherous waters with extreme caution, recognizing that genuine partnership cannot exist alongside economic warfare and disrespect for sovereign choices. The Global South must unite against such divide-and-rule tactics that have characterized Western engagement for centuries.